Business India ×
  Magazine:
Column

Published on: Nov. 30, 2020, 8:40 a.m.
Avoiding the perils of voting in boards
  • Online voting makes things more accurate and efficient than in the old-style meetings

By Dr M. Muneer and Ralph Ward

Directors of a board make decisions by following the prescribed voting protocol. The reason for the protocol is obvious in view of the crucial decisions that affect the future of the enterprise the board serves. The voting therefore needs to be transparent, accurate and secure.

Board members are supposed to deploy their fiduciary duties effectively and efficiently, and the voting is one part of fulfilling that. The chair is required to ensure a good voting procedure not dissimilar to Parliament procedures. Some enterprises have even written down the voting details in their memorandum of association.

The question of voting arises when a board director makes a motion for action, based on a proposal. In board meetings of yore – pre-pandemic era – there used to be steps to make a motion and for approving it. And whenever a board member makes a motion, the board has to act to approve or deny it.

In the good old days, the chairperson asks everyone around the table for a motion and a second, asks if there is any discussion, calls the vote, everyone muttersaye, and on to the next item. But in the new regime of online virtual board meetings, informed, legally defensible board votes have become both trickier and more technical. How do your board chair and company secretary assure remote board voting that can stand up to any subsequent legal scrutiny? 

The way most boards voted at their in-person sessions just doesn’t translate well to the virtual world. A recent EY survey found that, before the lockdown, 77 per cent of boards still voted by raising their hands at personal meetings. Taking this approach online means a dozen postage-stamp sized Zoom images all waving their hands (or maybe just swatting away a mosquito). And that’s assuming a unanimous vote. If there is a split, tallying the ayes and nays with precision, in a way that avoids second-guessing later, just won’t work. A voice teleconference, where the mumbled ayes and nays need to be sorted out, would be no less easy than guesswork on the part of the secretary taking minutes. 

The secretary recording votes in the minutes needs to make sure the tally is well documented. For either video or voice board meetings, this could mean a roll call vote with each member chiming in. This takes up a lot of time, though you will know if a member skipped out at the moment the vote was underway.

Before the Covid crisis, the few boards that met electronically often used hybrid measures to take and confirm votes. Directors could use e-mail to vote on an item. This was especially popular for unanimous written consents, or approval by ‘circulation’. Directors signed off on key items, and either emailed (or postal mailed) their responses. Again, there are problems in using these tools as standard meeting practices. They tend to be slow, uncertain and open to question. While the use of written consents has solid legal standing, board votes by e-mail may or may not be legally binding in your jurisdiction, so be sure to check with legal counsel. For example, there may be legal rules that an email vote can only be sent when the meeting itself is in session. In either case, the process is inefficient and open to second-guessing.

  • While the use of written consents has solid legal standing, board votes by e-mail may or may not be legally binding in your jurisdiction, so be sure to check with legal counsel

Your online board portal systems will have built-in tools for votes that create solid legal verification and confidentiality. Such tools electronically create a strong audit trail to show how the voting process was handled. While you will need to dig into the specifics of your own portal platform, most should create a time-stamped, verifiable record of exactly what the vote totals were, when the votes were cast, and who voted how. There is also a trail of when the vote fit in with the course of the board meeting, which can help prove adequate discussion time was provided prior to the voting.

All these data logging points may appear cumbersome, but theyare really good for voting through board portals. It creates a detailed record of your board actions outside the meeting minutes. That means your minutes may simply state a motion was approved, but the e-trail shows a divisive four-three vote. Or your minutes could suggest extensive board discussion, but the log time stamp shows you brought the item up on the agenda, discussed it, and voted, all within two minutes flat. Talk with your tech staff on how to vote electronically to show good, legal governance –withoutleaving a trail of breadcrumbs that could prove awkward in a court later. 

In the new format board meetings, online voting makes things more accurate and efficient than in the old-style meetings. As more and more boards are online today, e-voting will be here to stay and a number of online board tools have perfected the process of voting and resolution making. 

Corporate Report

How IRM Energy fuels growth, naturally

IRM Energy moves ahead with a clear vision towards transitioning to an energy-oriented company

Cover Feature

Air India 3.0: New wings

Irrespective of whether the final number is 470 or 840, Air India’s massive plane order is the best indication of its confident moves to reclaim its preeminent position in Indian skies

Special Report

How prepared are we to face El Nino

India gears up to tackle the heat wave and El Nino concerns which could spoil the rural party

Corporate Report

CapitaLand expands horizons

Singapore’s CapitaLand is looking to significantly enlarge its portfolio in India

E-MAGAZINE
Air India 3.0-new wings
One step forward two steps backward
Budget 2023
FROM THIS ISSUE

Corporate Report

Technology

Government

Government

Business Notes

Business Notes

Agriculture

The introduction of black pepper as an inter-crop in the sopari and coconut orchards, has enabled farmers to cultivate crops simultaneously

Skill Development

In 2020-21, the programme reached over 112,482 girls in urban and rural locations across six states in India, including 10,000 across Delhi

Collaboration

The event brought together stakeholders and changemakers to participate in a series of conversations on global trends and recent developments

Healthcare

The programme will focus on educating children on oral health and building awareness around the dangers of tobacco use

Airports

Airports set green deadline

Published on March 24, 2023, 12:01 p.m.

Currently Mumbai, Cochin and 25 other airports are using 100 per cent Green Energy

Government and Policy

TN plans to make RE share 50 per cent by 2030

Published on March 24, 2023, 11:44 a.m.

Tamil Nadu is banking high on renewable and green energy

Renewable Energy

Global green investment to triple by 2030: EC

Published on March 24, 2023, 11:22 a.m.

The bloc has also set a goal for carbon capture of 50 million tonnes by 2030

E-vehicles

Ola to raise $300m for expansion

Published on March 24, 2023, 11:03 a.m.

The fundraising would be managed by investment bank Goldman Sachs