Business India ×
Guest Column

Published on: Dec. 28, 2021, 4:46 p.m.
Waiting for a Big Ticket reform
  • We need PSUs like BSNL for a fair competition

By BK Syngal. The author is Former Chairman, VSNL

Connectivity is the essence of economic development without a doubt. To make connectivity, all pervasive five pillars are required for tsunami-like growth. They are: devices, content, applications, technology (mantra has to be application of technology to connect masses), and affordability. Simple economic principles tell us that with volumes comes economies of scale and affordability.

2021 saw some initiatives by way of incentives to produce more, relieve stress in the sector by grant of moratorium in payments of past dues to increase liquidity for investing in infrastructure. An important revision is the definition of what is deductible from gross revenues to arrive at Adjusted Gross Revenues (AGR) on which are based various government levies amounting to some 30 per cent-plus. These reforms are path-breaking indeed.

However, the moratorium in payment by four years does not come free. It carries a burden of interest costs for deferred payment against a pious hope that industry would become more efficient to generate enough surpluses to take care of the interest burden. Most likely nearer the date they might revert to waivers of interest payments in typical ‘Yeh Dil Maange More’ style.

Of course there are other reforms like abolition of bank guarantees, revision in calculations of penalties which were ballooning with each passing year, accompanied by rationalisation of the interest rate at which the penalties were calculated. Yet another path-breaking amendment was revoking retro taxation. Within weeks of the death of the architect of retro taxation, the Government was blackmailed and conned into accepting that retro taxation was bad in law (Tax Terrorism as termed by some), though practiced world-wide, especially in the UK, for the good of the public since the 19th century.

Be that as it may, the logjam breaking reforms taken by the government were bold, pragmatic and investor friendly. However, a key, but fundamental reform is yet to be taken, which is rationalisation of levies. Recently there has been a statement that telecom is for the public good, revenue maximisation from telecom is not the aim of the government but proliferation of affordable public service is. It is planned to auction spectrum for variety of services in 2022.

The hint was to reduce input costs by rational expectations in the pricing of spectrum. Here let me pose a question: Why is the industry being taxed linearly and in perpetuity having to pay around 30 per cent-plus in levies?  That in itself is the antithesis of the stated objectives. A linear taxation is nothing, but revenue maximisation by taxing the success of the industry, resulting in reduced surpluses to plough back into building infrastructure, increasing borrowings, etc.

It is time these levies are revisited in order to have a scientific approach of spectrum input costs, and ongoing receivables in the form of levies. Introduce a concept of revenue neutralisation. I am by no means suggesting that scarce national resource be distributed as in the 2G scam era, but certainly by a market driven economic price discovery.

  • Why is the industry being taxed linearly and in perpetuity having to pay around 30 per cent-plus in levies?

Any irrational bidding is to the account of the bidders, and government must not be accused of revenue maximisation. This objective would be achieved by making adequate spectrum available for applications in a technology agnostic manner. On the connectivity front there is no point getting tied to a technology. Today there are multiple options to reach out to the consumer – Fibre, Wi-Fi, Fixed Wireless Access (FWA) and the ubiquitous cellular. There are wide variety of satellite based services in LEO, MEO, Elliptical, Intermediate circular orbit (ICO) and GEO configurations.

The approach must not be driven by the supplier of gear in the industry, but by the need and means to provide connectivity by the best and affordable technology. Gone are the days when industry ruled the roost. In the years going forward the technology should drive connectivity depending upon usage, application and how soon technology could be deployed. Such an approach requires out-of-the-box thinking for regulation, policy and implementation. Frankly, the licensing regime could be changed to a simple piece of paper with a quantum of levies, and the acquisition of key resource spectrum either through auctions or liberal sharing, trading etc. 

Yet another big-ticket reform one would like to seek is the survival of MTNL/BSNL; over the past 21 years value has been destroyed in the hope of a proper value discovery. It has become akin to chasing a rainbow. For healthy competition survival of the two PSUs is essential or else we are heading for a private sector duopoly. Summing up, rationalisation of levies, availability of adequate spectrum, reasonable transparently priced, a technologically agnostic approach to provide connectivity and revival of PSUs to have fair competition is what I would wish for.

Cover Feature

Modi's coalition challenge

A shrunk mandate for Modi means compromises and problems in governance

Corporate Report

RPEL undergoes a metamorphosis

RPEL focusses on innovation in high-value stainless-steel products for growth

Corporate Report

How SLMG became a force to reckon with

India’s largest independent Coca-Cola bottler SLMG Beverages plans for a future ready organisation

Special Report

PSU shares: Back on investors’ radar

With markets stabilising, PSU shares are again being favoured by investors

Coalition Challenge
Up, Up and Up
Indian Elections and Markets


Private Equity




Corporate Report


The introduction of black pepper as an inter-crop in the sopari and coconut orchards, has enabled farmers to cultivate crops simultaneously

Skill Development

In 2020-21, the programme reached over 112,482 girls in urban and rural locations across six states in India, including 10,000 across Delhi


The event brought together stakeholders and changemakers to participate in a series of conversations on global trends and recent developments


The programme will focus on educating children on oral health and building awareness around the dangers of tobacco use


German BioEnergy enters Indian market

Published on Aug. 17, 2023, 11:54 a.m.

BioEnergy will showcase its innovative biogas technology in India


Ather looks to double its market share

Published on Aug. 17, 2023, 11:26 a.m.

Ather aims to produce 20,000 units every month, soon

Green Hydrogen

‘Kerala Hydrogen ecosystem a model for all states’

Published on Aug. 17, 2023, 11:06 a.m.

German Development Agency, GIZ is working on a roadmap for a green hydrogen cluster in Kochi

Renewable Energy

Adani Green eyes 45GW RE

Published on Aug. 17, 2023, 10:45 a.m.

AGEL set to play a big role in India’s carbon neutrality target