Business India ×

Published on: Jan. 14, 2021, 1:07 p.m.
Government must initiate a way out
  • Illustration: Panju Ganguli

By Business India Editorial

The farmers’ protests show no signs of abatement even after eight rounds of talks. Tens of thousands of farmers have been camping near entry points to New Delhi since 26 November, unmindful of the deadly virus that has felled so many people. In yet another display of their organisational muscle, they now plan to take out a massive tractor rally on 26 January to effectively overshadow (and perhaps even disrupt) the Republic Day parade. To give in to the demands of the agitating farmers and scrap the laws would be an uncharacteristic admission of defeat for Modi and his strongman image. That would also negate his claim of transforming Indian agriculture. 

But letting the unrest linger could cause chaos in food markets, alienate urban consumers at a time when food inflation is rising alarmingly and potentially derail the post-Covid recovery. It also sends out a terrible signal abroad, particularly when Sikh farmers from Punjab have been able to whip up considerable support in the western hemisphere. Also, the Centre cannot just abdicate its duty to listen to its citizens’ grievances and leave the matter for the court to decide.

Nobody disputes the fact that, if India is to grow reasonably, farming must come out of its 3 per cent (or 3.5 per cent, as the latest CSO estimates indicate for this year) growth rut. Productivity of labour, land, fertilisers and water has to improve. Massive private investments are needed in storage and processing for the country’s 2 per cent share of global agricultural exports to increase. Modi has come to the conclusion that the answer lies in free markets and in turning the entire country into a free trade area, benefiting 119 million farmers and 144 million farmhands, plus their families. Farmers from Punjab, Haryana and parts of Uttar Pradesh view this move as an end to institutional state support which, they fear, will allow profiteering corporations to rush into the resulting vacuum. 

A compromise solution would require consultation – something woefully lacking when Modi’s government rammed the bills through a voice vote in Parliament in September. A way out of the logjam could be the creation of an additional law that will give the agitating farmers some solace and protect their income. The additional law can guarantee a basic farm income, benchmarked to every state’s agricultural value added. Once the principles of free market start delivering results, the law can be phased out.

The solution is predicated in the fact that an influential section of India’s agriculture – most notably in Punjab and Haryana – relies excessively on selling rice and wheat to the government at so-called minimum support prices. The purchase takes place in mandis. One of the bills gave farmers the freedom to sell their produce outside the designated yards – and without having to pay taxes and fees to the state governments. For grain cultivators, the worry is that, if the mandi falls into disuse, what will happen if the government stop buying from them at guaranteed prices? The fear isn’t irrational. The Food Corporation of India’s granaries are already overflowing. There is a limit to how much it can buy or store.

  • To give in to the demands of the agitating farmers and scrap the laws would be an uncharacteristic admission of defeat for Modi and his strongman image. That would also negate his claim of transforming Indian agriculture

One of the farmers’ demands is for legal backing for minimum support prices for wheat, rice and cotton – something that could have ugly consequences for public finances and also draw the ire of the WTO. In WTO parlance, MSPs fall in what is called the Amber Box category, which thus have to be capped at 10 per cent of the total value of the concerned product, as required under the Agreement on Agriculture (which India has signed).

If India’s domestic support exceeds the permissible limit, it would stand in violation of this agreement. Indeed, India’s public stockholding programme and MSP have been hotly debated at the WTO between the developed and developing blocs. The US and Canada have been opponents of India’s food security and domestic support programmes.

Once the farmer is weaned off the streets, the government needs to change the social contract of farming, particularly in Punjab, where farming households benefit about Rs1.25 lakh in subsidised fertiliser and free electricity required to pump groundwater. It is well accepted that a water-guzzling crop like paddy isn’t suitable for Punjab as overuse of groundwater is depleting aquifers. There is also the issue of the burning of paddy stubble, which is causing hazardous pollution in the national capital. New cash crops need to be introduced.

The other tweaks will involve correcting design flaws, say, in contract farming law which, small landholders fear, will subject them to exploitation. Indeed, the power imbalance between the big and small needs a relook. But only after providing farmers downside protection first will they believe that free markets will bring them prosperity.

Cover Feature

Business Schools: Back in action

How future managers will handle challenges

Corporate Report

India Cement’s journey continues

At 75, India Cements is a heady cocktail of a story


How to energise the mining sector

The mining industry emphasises on the optimal use of mineral reserves

Special Report

India's G20 presidency: Luckier than Indonesia?

As India assumes G20 presidency, it will have to go by consensus to keep China on board

B-schools: Back in Action
COP27-Success or Failure?
The consumption rebound

Corporate Report

Guest Column

Guest Column

Guest Column

Guest Column

Guest Column

Company Feature

Classrooms go live, thanks to Airtel

Published on April 5, 2022, 11:25 a.m.

Despite the pandemic, Bharti Foundation has ensured that children are not deprived of learning opportunities


Collaborative excellence

Published on April 4, 2022, 8:53 p.m.

A policy perspective for meeting SDG-9 in low resource setting of developing economies


Innovation and infrastructure

Published on April 4, 2022, 8:10 p.m.

India is well-positioned to become a model of corporate sustainability


‘More for less’

Published on April 1, 2022, 10:12 p.m.

The merger of technology and SDGs – A game-changing win of the era


Matter launches e-bikes

Published on Nov. 23, 2022, 2:09 p.m.

The bike has been designed for travelling on both trails and roadways


Demystifying population woes

Published on Nov. 23, 2022, 1:51 p.m.

Regions that have more people do not necessarily emit more carbon


Clean Electric raises $2.2 million

Published on Nov. 23, 2022, 1:24 p.m.

Clean Electric gets a funding boost


Banking on green

Published on Nov. 23, 2022, 1 p.m.

Banks have increased their lending to EV purchases